Monday, March 15, 2021

Prof. Baldev Singh Narang – An Obituary

 

Prof. Baldev Singh Narang – An Obituary

A Guru of Shastria Sangeet – Indian Classical Music, Prof. Baldev Singh Narang of Jalandhar passed away on March 2, 2021 at an age of about 75. The news of his demise came as a shock to the music lovers and cultural circles of Jalandhar and beyond. Ustad Baldev Singh Narang, who was popularly called Guruji, was a much respected and acclaimed personality in the world of classical music not only in India but abroad too. I did not know him personally till 2008. One of my cousins, Gurdial Mahey of Birmingham in the UK,

With Prof. Baldev Narang and Sangat Ram

brought him to India House, my official residence in Edinburg in Scotland, sometime in 2008 when I was the Consul General of India there. They stayed with as house-guests. Only then I could know that Narang Sahib was a vocalist of his own standing. He regaled us for several evenings with his classical singing over the readily available  Keyboard at our home over lovely and enjoyable relaxed atmosphere in the summer of Edinburgh. One evening I took him and Gurdial to a cultural function of the Indian community where I was the Guest of Honour. Judging the mood of the audience, I suggested to the organizers to listen to my guest Baldev Singh Narang and they immediately accommodated him in the programme. Oh my goodness, Narang Sahib did the trick and made the audience spell bound with his masterly performance. It was a rewarding occasion. Later on my retirement, I came back to my roots in Jalandhar and developed close relationship with Narang Sahib. He


was the soul and heart of the cultural life, particularly music, in Jalandhar.  During his life time, I was told, he was conferred with all important awards and recognitions in the field of classical music and rendition. Narang Sahib was Head of the Music Department in the local DAV College and taught music with authority and involvement. Some of the prominent singers like Hans Raj Hans, Jasbir Jassi, Sarabjit Cheems, Master Slim, Balkar Sidhu among others benefited from the training and teaching of Ustad Narang and earned laurels in their profession and career. An establish music master, Tejwant Kittu is also a student of the Guru Narang.  Baldev Narang remained a much acclaimed performer at the legendary Harballabh Sangeet Mela at Jalandhar for many years and later remained with the management of the Mela as an adviser and patron.

It was a matter of great satisfaction and pride that Baldev Narang was a son of the soil belonging to Nakodar. Music was running in his veins as his father Pandit Kesar Chand was a musician himself who initiated Baldev his son to the realm of classical music. The son made him proud with his musical prowess. The Antim Ardas of Guru Baldev Narang was held on March 14 at Guru Ravidass Bhawan in Jalandhar in which the Who’s Who of the cultural and musical life of Jalandhar and around was present to pay tributes to the departed soul and rightly so. The fragrance of the classical music was floating around as Alama Iqbal had said:

Uthaye Kuch Waraq Lale Ne, Kuch Nargis Ne, Kuch Gul Ne
Chaman Mein Har Taraf Bikhri Huwi Hai Dastan Meri


(Some leaves were picked up by the tulip, some by the narcissus, some by the rose
My story is scattered around everywhere in the garden)

Urha Li Qumriyon Ne, Tootiyon Ne, Andleebon Ne
Chaman Walon Ne Mil Kar Loot Li Tarz-e-Faghan Meri


(The turtle‐doves, parrots, and nightingales pilfered away
The garden’s denizens jointly robbed away my plaintive way)

POSTSCRIPT:

On reading my blog, One of close friends in Jalandhar, Principal Jagdish Joshi himself a poet of standing with many books to his credit informed me that he was a close friend of Ustad Baldev Narang with regard to their cultural and intellectual pursuits. Narang Sahib sang Joshi Sahib's at least 8 Gazals which were available on YouTube. He recited on phone the Matla (opening line) of one the Gazals sung by Ustad  Narang which is worth sharing to salute both the masters - Joshi and Narang in respect of their respective skills and prowess of writing and singing:

कोई पत्थर खुदा नहीं होता ;

खुदा खुद खुदा नहीं होता!




            


Tuesday, March 2, 2021

Guru Ravidass Gurpurab at Bootan Mandi Jalandhar – My Musings

 

Guru Ravidass Gurpurab at Bootan Mandi Jalandhar – My Musings

Bootan Mandi, native place of well to do followers of Guru Ravidass in Jalandhar, has traditionally been the nerve centre of activities pertaining to dalits not only in Punjab but also throughout India and beyond. For the past hundred years or so, as per oral history, Guru Ravidass’s Janam Dihada (Jayanti/Gurpurab) is celebrated with enthusiasm and gaiety here with traditional Jaloos (Shoba Yatra or Nagar Kirtan) starting from Bootan Mandi which terminates back at Bootan Mandi after covering a long route of about 10 km. through the important thoroughfares of the town. The traditional Tamak – Big

Traditional Drum - Tamak

Drum/Nagada leads the Yatra to announce the arrival of the Shoba Yatra which is generally played by men. This year, it was gratifying to note that young ladies were doing the honour, a handsome tribute to the lofty philosophy of the Gurus and our constitution giving equal status to the women folk and rightly so.

Over the years, the Disha and Dasha (shape and scope) of the two day celebrations at Bootan Mandi, have been evolving to meet the fast changing scenario of not only social and economic status of the dalits in the region and beyond but also the emerging political clout which dalits are holding, thanks to the efforts and struggle of Babasaheb Ambedkar, Babu Mangoo Ram Mugowalia and Manyawar Kanshi Ram. In the early years, these celebrations used to be a simple spiritual manifestation of the followers of Guru Ravidass in the region under the influence of Ad-dharm Mandal of Babu Mangoo Ram Mugowalia and Sants like Sarwan Dass of Dera Ballan on the out-skirts of Jalandhar and Hira Dass of  Dera Chak Hakim  near Phagwara among others. Babasaheb Ambedkar appeared on the scene and his visit to Bootan Mandi in October, 1951 and growing economic well being of leather merchants of the area tended to change the direction towards political orientation to the celebrations. Dalit youth of the area started taking interest and provided positive inputs. The celebrations became more educative and an exercise in generating awareness by way of organizing Kavi-Darbars, bringing out of souvenirs, printing and exchanging greeting cards, decorating and decking the entire route of the Jaloos – Shoba Yatra with colouful banners, arches, buntings etc. beginning  the mid 1960s. I may add with a sense of belonging and satisfaction that I as a young student fully associated with these activities and held the position of

Shobha Yatra, 2021

General Secretary of Guru Ravidass Welfare Society of Bootan Mandi for many successive years in the latter half of 1960s and my younger brother Paramjit held the fort for almost 10 years later. The increasing economic and social clout of young and successful businessmen of Bootan Mandi like Sat Paul Mal, Surinder Mahey who also rose to be the Mayor of Jalandhar, Manohar Mahey, Prem Shant, Mool Raj, Avinash Chander who also remained Chief Parliamentary Secretary in successive Akali Governments, inter alia, added to the pomp and show of the celebrations of Gurpurab and other related events. The two Gurudwaras in the Mohalla were given a facelift with added facilities befitting to the sites. The Bootan Mandi two-day annual celebrations were virtually turned into a huge mela on the calendar of events of the city towards the end of the century and first decade of the 21st century. All political leaders of standing felt obliged to come and pay obeisance at Guru Ravidass Dham, join the Shoba Yatra, join the spiritual darbars and register their presence at the much awaited and acclaimed Sangeet Darbar to conclude the ceremonies. The list of singers at the Sangeet Darbar, the climax
Shri Guru Ravidass Dham Bootan Mandi

event, reads like a ‘Who’s Who’ of the cultural and musical fraternity from Narinder Biba to Hans Raj Hans to Master Saleem to Noora Sisters (their gread mother Bibi Nooran belonged to Bootan Mandi) to Ginni Mahi and all other top-notch singers of Punjab, with the catch phrase -  Bootan Mandi Ajao Jene Dekhana Nazara eh ( Come to Bootan Mandi to enjoy). Hans Raj Hans even improvised the famous Punjabi lore, Mahia and said – Do Patar Anaran De; Jis Sanu Milana Hove – Behde Ajae Chamaran De. The importance of Bootan Mandi may be gauged from the fact that icons and  leaders like Ambedkar, Mangoo Ram, Joginder Nath Mandal, Jagjivan Ram, swaran Singh, Nijlangappa, Chand Ram, B.P. Maurya, Kanshi Ram, Mayawati, I.K. Gujral, L.K. Advani, Ram Nath Kovind, Ram Bilas Paswan, almost all CM’s of Punjab among others visited Bootan Mandi at one occasion or the other.

The glory of Guru Ravidass Jayanti kept on increasing with spontaneous participation of lakhs and lakhs of followers of Guru Ravidass and also merry makers to enjoy the Mela and celebrations over the year. But every good thing also has a negative side, it is said. The Mela aspect of the event is gaining strength and currency in tandem with the rising profile of the community in general. But the agenda and purpose of the event got diluted beginning the decade of

Book stall at Gurpurab Mela

2020. Personal rivalry, jealousy, family quarrels, decreasing economic profile of the so called Seths of Bootan Mandi and also rising political profile of Akalis, BJP, AAP to replace the traditional stronghold of Congress and Republican Party/BSP etc. The Gurpurab is celebrated as it used to be but the underlying current indicated that it was losing steam under the self-appointed leadership of spent forces that is ‘Chale Hue Kartoos’ in Punjabi parlance. They are full of ego and don’t want to pass on the baton to the younger generation with sheer vested motives. It is a matter of concern to many like me who have emotional attachment and sense of belonging not only to Bootan Mandi but also to the lofty ideals and philosophy of the great Guru. These are my personal views which I decided to share with my fellow Bootan Mandians and the community at large though with a lot of remorse and pain. I have no intension to criticize or oppose anybody individually or collectively. The sole motivation to write this piece is to raise an early alarm before the situation worsens and the glory of my native place Bootan Mandi which is called the ‘Capital of Dalits’; informally, is damaged. I pray to Guru Ravidass to bless us with soul and mind to understand and arrest the decline in our thinking and approach and enable us to rectify the situation in the larger interests of the area and the community at large. Let us be tolerant. Let us learn from each other. Let us encourage the younger generation to come forward and take over. The sooner the better. With these humble submissions, I conclude with a quote from Allama Iqbal’s nazam:

Hawaida  Aaj Apne Zakhm-e-Pinhan Kar Ke Chorun Ga
Lahoo Ro Ro Ke Mehfil Ko Gulistan Kar Ke Chorun Ga

I will surely exhibit all my hidden wounds today
I will surely change assembly to a garden with blood‐mixed tears

Jalana Hai Mujhe Har Shama-e-Dil Ko Souz-e-Pinhan Se
Teri Tareek Raaton Mein Charaghan Kar Ke Chorun Ga

I have to light every heart’s candle with hidden pathos
I will surely create bright illumination in your darkness

Parona Aik Hi Tasbeeh Mein In Bikhare Danon Ko
Jo Muskhil Hai, To Iss Mushkil Ki Asan Kar Ke Chorun Ga

If stringing these scattered pearls in a single rosary
Is difficult, I will surely make this difficult task easy

Monday, February 15, 2021

Book Review – Mahapran Jogendra Nath Mandal – Jiwan Aur Vichar

 

Book Review – Mahapran Jogendra Nath Mandal – Jiwan Aur Vichar

Jogendra Nath Mandal remained an unsung hero of dalits after the recognized icon Babasaheb Ambedkar. I read some pieces about Mandal Sahib from here and there but had not read much as Jogendra Nath Mandal somehow got pushed to the margins of history by sheer quirk of geo-political and socio-economic ground realities in the 1920s to 1960s in the run up to the partition of India and creation of India and Pakistan; the period in which he played an important role as a lead player. On the birth anniversary of Jogendra Nath Mandal on January 29, I got an e-mail from Prof. Ishtiaq Ahmed of Stockholm University in Sweden which made some very informative observations on Jogendra Nath Mandal which were very kindly forwarded to me, as usual, by my senior colleague and mentor Ambassador Bal Anand. On one of my recent visits to a book exhibition at Desh Bhagat Yaadgar Hall in Jalandhar, I could get a small book of 120 pages in Hindi written by Sheelpriya  Baudh –


Mahapran Jogendra Nath Mandal – Jiwan and Vichar published by Samyak Prakashan. On reading the book, which is in no way a well researched work, nevertheless, I could get some informative material on Jogendra Nath Mandal which may be of interest. The author Sheelpriya Baudh has not claimed any affinity or firsthand interaction with Jogen Da, the nick name of Mandal Sahib. It was just a chance meeting of the author with one of the close relations of Jogen Da, A.K. Mandal, a senior professional with the Indian Railways which prompted him to write about the great leader of his times as stated by him in the introduction of the book.

Jogendra Nath Mandal was born in a nondescript and poor dalit family on January 29, 1904 in the district of Barisal in East Bengal which ultimately became East Pakistan on partition of India in August, 1947 and later Bangladesh in December, 1971. Since his uncle (Chacha), Ram Krishan did not have their own issue; they adopted Jogendra Nath Mandal and gave him the best possible upbringing with their meager sources and lowly social status in the caste ridden society. Jogendra was a brilliant and dedicated child who passed his Matriculation in 1924 in first division as he was admitted to school at the age of 8 under difficult social and economic hardships. Jogendra was keen to get higher education and he got all support from his uncle Ram Krishan in joining the college. Meanwhile Jogendra got married to Kamla Devi in a somewhat economically better off family. His father in law agreed to finance his further education. In spite of numerous hurdles, Jogendra, with his grit and determination, continued his higher education of BA in 1929 from Brij Mohan College at Barisal, MA and, LL.B from Universities in Dacca and Calcutta respectively. While in his college and university days, he showed lot of concern for the pitiable condition of his under-privileged brethren in the community. He resented attempts by his fellow students of upper castes to refrain him from joining Sarswati Pooja. Once he was admonished for entering Kali Mandir at Barisal, being a low caste, and desecration of the deity. Jogendra was an orator with a great sense of argument and logic even in his college and university days. In 1936, he started practice in Calcutta High Court to earn his bread and butter but due to caste prejudices could not succeed. He shifted to his native place Barisal and established himself as a successful practitioner of law and also started participating in public affairs with focus on matters of concern and interest to the socially and economically marginalized sections of the society and also communal harmony between Muslim and Hindu communities. Jogendra Nath Mandal’s first public recognition came in 1936 with his election to the Member of Municipal Council of Barisal which was further complimented by his election to the provincial assembly in 1937 under the formula of reserved seats for depressed classes. With the support of forces opposed to the Congress Party, Mandal Sahib won with an impressive margin of votes as an Independent against a Congress heavy-weight, Saral Kumar Dutt. Mahatma Gandhi was not happy on these developments and castigating the local Congress leadership on the victory of Jogen Da, as quoted by Sheelpriya Baudh, said, “For the success of a real public worker, no trademark is required. Real service and love for the masses is his only trademark”. Mandal Sahib was an active politician. He fought for reservation for dalits in education and government jobs for depressed classes as agreed to in the Poona Pact signed between Ambedkar and Gandhi in 1932 in the wake of the Communal Award of PM Ramsey MacDonald. He, in cooperation with other dalit leaders, established Independent Scheduled Caste Party. There were two political formations in Bengal; one was led by Fazlulalhaq and Syama Prasad Mookerjee and the second by Khawaja Nazimuddin. Mandal created his own independent group as a caucus to take care of the interests of dalits. Khawaja Nazimuddin showed inclination and roped in Jogen Da and appointed him as Minister in his government. Jogendra proved to be a vocal Minister particularly with regard to the issues pertaining to dalits and other weaker sections of the society. He stood with Subhash Chandra Bose in 1941-42 with regard to Bose’s disagreements with Congress Party and Mahatma Gandhi. Jogen Da was a fearless leader. The book under review has mentioned an incident in 1943-44 when he stood like a rock on the issue of employment to dalits. I quote from page 35 of the book which would say all. On a heated argumentative discussion in a meeting, Jogen Da responded angrily to MLA Hamidulhaq Chaudhary and said

“Mr. Hamidulhaq Chaudhary apni yeh lal ankhen kisi aur ko dikhana. Mujhe bhi ankhen dikhana atta hai. Mein apne mantripad ke dawara uchit kaya kar raha hoon. Mein is mantripad ki seva karne nahin aya hoon. Yeh mantripad kisi ki kirpa ka fal nahin jo meri jholi mein dal diya gya hai. Yeh jo rang bhawan hum logon dawara nirmit kia gya hai use mein 24 ghanton mein katam bhi kar sakta hoon” – Mr Chaudhary please show this anger to someone else. I can also be angry. I am doing my job a Minister. I am not here to enjoy the Ministership which is not a gift given to me. Whatever we have created with our own efforts could also be destroyed in 24 hours, if I want.

Joginder Nath Mandal proved his mettle in Bengal and started spreading his wings beyond Bengal in 1942 by the time Babasaheb Ambedkar had made his mark in the Indian political firmament. In March, 1942, dalits arranged a pan-India meeting in Delhi to take stock of the emerging political situation in the wake of Cripps Mission in which Babasaheb Ambedkar and Joginder Nath Mandal also participated. It was said to be the first formal meeting of two dalits leaders. Both the leaders could develop good rapport with each other with regard to the future political space of dalits. It was decided to float an all-India political outfit for the purpose. The next meeting was held at Nagpur in July, 1942. Joginder Nath Mandal along with his associates in the Independent Scheduled Castes Party also participated in the Nagpur meeting and joined hands with other leaders in which it was decided to rename the All India Depressed Classes Federation, an outfit started by Ambedkar in 1930, as the All India Scheduled Caste Federation to carry forward the agenda of the side lined segments of the society. The Bengal Chapter of the new party was headed by Joginder Nath Mandal himself. In the subsequent years, Ambedkar and Joginder intensified their contact and cooperation, Mandal Sahib as a Minister in the Bengal Government and Ambedkar as a Member of the Viceroy’s Council in spite of some complaints of local Bengali leaders against Jogen Da on account of his links with Subhash Chander Bose and seeking help from Congress Party on various occasions. The book has included a couple of letters exchanged between Ambedkar and Jogen da which give a positive flavor of the rapport and understanding that existed between the two stalwarts’ of the time. Ambedkar further cemented the mutual understanding and respect when he honored Jogen Da to formally open the Ambedkar School of Politics in Poona in October, 1945. The glorious chapter of Jogen Da’s contribution was yet to open. He was the lone successful MLA on the ticket of All India Scheduled Caste Federation among the 30 odd reserved seats with 26 of the Congress Party and three independents. He became a Minister in H.S. Suharawardy’s government in April, 1946 as a Hindu nominee for communal balance in the Cabinet. Now an epoch making chapter opens in May, 1946. The Constituent Assembly was to be formed by the members elected by the provincial assemblies. The process started and Congress Party ‘closed all doors and windows; even the ventilators’ for the entry of Babasaheb Ambedkar to the Constituent Assembly from anywhere in India. It is a well documented fact. Dalits all over India were worried. The book gives some insights of the situation. It was Jogendra Nath Mandal and his associates and supporters who came forward and invited Dr. B.R. Ambedkar to come to Bengal and they would send him to the Constituent Assembly. It was a proposal engulfed with so many uncertainties. But there was no other option. Ambedkar reached Calcutta in the second half of June, 1946 and accepted the offer. Both Jogen Da and Ambedkar with the explicit understandings with Khawaja Nazimuddin did their best to gather support. Congress Party employed every trick to see that Ambedkar may not succeed in filing his papers for the election as an independent candidate. With lot of grit and planning and even aggressive posture on the part of dalits from the Doaba region of Punjab  engaged in leather business  in Calcutta, all these designs were defeated. On July 17, 1946, the election day, it was a do or die situation. The book gives a detailed account of these events. The supporters of Ambedkar led by Punjabi leather tanners stormed the Assembly building where voting was to take place. One Budh Singh from a village Tallan in Jalandhar district of Punjab brandished a sword and declared that anybody seen trying to stop or negate Ambedkar’s election will not be spared “yeh talwaren gadharon ke khoon se lath path ho janengi aur mein apne jiwan ki ahuti de doonga” – this sword will be bathed with the blood of traitors and I will sacrifice my life. Jogen Da himself led that show of anger and strength. On counting of votes on July 20, Ambedkar got elected to the Constituent Assembly hands down with a huge support. It has been revealed in the book that even more than 6 Congress MLAs defying the party whip voted for Ambedkar. It was a sigh of relief to the entire dalit community. Jogen Da made his mark as a leader of dalits along with Ambedkar. The rest is history. If Ambedkar was not elected to the Constituent Assembly from Bengal under the leadership of Jogendra Nath Mandal, the history of the constitution making would have been different.

The next very important phase in the life of Jogendra Nath Mandal came with the formation of Interim Government under the leadership of Jawaharlal Nehru in August 1946. The Muslim League and dalits like Ambedkar opposed to Congress Party were not accommodated in it. Meanwhile, communal situation was tense particularly in Bengal. Jogen Da was already serving in the Suharwardy Government in Bengal. The political scenario in Delhi was changing by every passing day. One fine morning, Suharwardy summoned Jogen Da to his office and asked him whether he would like to join the Interim Government in Delhi from the Muslim League quota and


handed him a letter of Muhammad Ali Jinnah in this regard. It was a real surprise. Jogen Da, considering the treatment of dalits by the Congress and Hindu prejudices, accepted the offer of Jinnah. Obviously, it was not liked by Mahatma Gandhi and other Hindu leaders. Accordingly, Jogendra Nath Mandal joined the Interim Government in November 4, 1946. It was a difficult decision but took the plunge with explicit understanding and blessings of Babasaheb Ambedkar and the community leaders in larger interests of dalits of not only Bengal but of the united India. Jogen Da, as Law Minister in the Interim Government led by Jawaharlal Nehru, wrote to Ambedkar on May 30, 1947 and solicited his advice as to what should be done by him to safe guard the interests of dalits in the emerging political scenario to which Ambedkar replied on June 2, 1947, the text of the letter is available in the book. The reality of partition of India into two countries on the basis of two nation theory of Muslim League and its leadership led by Jinnah was being realized as Congress and its leadership led by Nehru was amenable to the idea of partition. Jogen Da and other leaders like Sarat Chandra Bose, elder brother of Subhash Chandra Bose among others floated the idea of independent Bengal, as stated in the book, but could not go far as it was already too late. It was certain that the Janam and Karam Bhoomi of Jogen Da were to become East Pakistan. These ground realities coupled with high-handedness of Congrss Party and Hindu leaders in dealing with dalits in the caste ridden society on one hand and some soft corner and promises of Muslim leadership including Jinnah to provide due space to dalits in the new dispensation on the other made Mandal Sahib to side with Pakistan. Accordingly on the advice and directions of Jinnah, he left for the new capital city of Pakistan on August 5, 1947. Pakistan came into being as a nation on August, 1947 under the leadership of Mohammad Ali Jinnah as Governor General and Liaquat Ali Khan as PM. As a political masterstroke to assuage the ruffled feelings of Hindus including dalits, Joginder Nath Mandal was retained as the first Law Minister of Pakistan. Was it a design or chance that Dr. B.R. was made the first law Minister of free India and Joginder Nath Mandal of free Pakistan, both dalit leaders of their own standing belonging to the All India Scheduled Castes Federation? Jogen Da established his credentials as a vocal leader of a secular mind with particular focus on rights and space of minority Hindus and dalits as the Law Minister of Pakistan. He was doing his job well with clear support and understanding of Pakistani Head of State Qaid-e-Azam Jinnah. But the things were getting difficult with planned and willful violence by majority Muslims against minority Hindus. Jogen Da Jinnah threatened to resign from the Cabinet. The details of an interesting tiff with Jinnah are given in the book at page 103. Jinnah first tried to underplay the resentment of Jogen Da but later sensing the mood said, as quoted in the book, “Mr. Mandal patience in politics is the essence of success. I was just testing your patience. I am equally perturbed over the situation in East Pakistan. I have ordered for a special flight for going to East Pakistan accompanied by you so as to solve the problem.” Jogen Da also kept Ambedkar in India on the loop and kept him informed of the emerging communal situation in Pakistan particularly with regard to dalits. The book contains letters of Ambedkar which he wrote to PM Jawaharlal Nehru and his Cabinet colleague K.C. Nyogi. Jogen Da’s hopes were shattered particularly the sudden death of Qaid-e-Azam Jinnah on December 11, 1948. The new leader, Liquat Ali Khan was not supportive of Jogen Da. He did not like Jogen Da’s stance on treatment to Hindu and other minorities in Pakistan and tried to sideline him. In June 1950, Jogen Da, being Labour Minister of Pakistan, was not sent to a meeting of the International Labour Conference (ILO). Jogen Da sensed trouble and in one of meetings with Liaquat Ali offered to resign and said, as per the book, “If you wish, I may slip down’. There were rumors that Jogen Da even be dismissed from the Cabinet. In September, 1950, he got a telegram that in Calcutta his son Jagdish Chandra Mandal was seriously down with malaria and he should immediately come to see his son. Jogen Da came to Calcutta and fell sick himself. Meanwhile, political developments and communal situation in Pakistan was generating a worrisome situation. Pakistan was increasingly ceasing to be a country of secular and democratic values. With consultation with his associates in India, Jogendra Nath Mandal decided to stay back in Calcutta and resigned on October 8, 1950 from the coveted positions he held in Pakistan and sent his resignation to PM Liaquat Ali Khan. The text of the resignation letter is given in the book on page 106 and I quote from it for the benefit of readers but I doubt, given the language of the said letter, that is the correct text, “The treatment meted to Hindus and other minorities by the so called Nazi Muslims/Gundas during the recent riots in February, 1950, I firmly believe that the entire Pakistan is not a place for Hindus to live. They even be converted by brutal force.”  This chapter of short lived ‘tryst with Pakistan’ of Jogen Da came to an end. Only researchers, scholars and historians would evaluate and analyse these momentous decisions for the benefit of the general public. But it is for sure that Joginder Nah Mandal was a leader by his right.

On return from Pakistan, Mandal Sahib engaged himself in public service with regard to the displaced people. During the course of his activism, he went to jail several times in West Bengal. Meanwhile, Ambedkar also resigned from Jawaharlal Nehru’s Cabinet in 1951. Jogendra Nath Mandal did not agree with one of the reasons of Ambeddkar’s resignation on the issue of division of the state of Jammu and Kashmir, as mentioned in the book under review. In the run up to the first elections in 1952 under the new constitution of India, Jogen Da floated a new political outfit called United Peoples Organisation and contested elections but could not make any dent. He himself lost like Babasaheb Ambedkar and his All India Scheduled Caste Federation. After Ambedkar’s passing away in December, 1956, Jogen Da tried to gather likeminded forces to carry forward the legacy of Babsaheb Ambedkar but could not do much. He died as an unsung hero on October 5, 1968.

As a tail-piece, may I mention here that I had an opportunity to see and listen to Joginder Nath Mandal at my native place at Bootan Mandi in Jalandhar in Punjab sometime in 1964-65 as a young lad in my formative years.  I vividly remember he was a tall man nicely dressed in white kurta and dhoti. He spoke in English which was interpreted by an up-coming local leader at that time and a staunch Ambedkarite,  Lahori Ram Balley. I don’t remember the contents of his speech but somehow feel that these must be of value.

All said and done, Mahapran Jogendra Nath Mandal – Jiwan Aur Vichar is a book that provides some basic facts to introduce the leader. I hope some well researched book about Jogendra Nath Mandal comes in the future with more and an authentic version of his life and mission. I conclude with a quote from Babarnama given at page 117 of the book:

अरसे  से कोई न मेरा यार न मेरा दयार है ;

पल भर को भी नहीं मुझे हासिल करार है,

आने को अपनी मर्जी से मैं आया था यहाँ ;

जाने का पर  यहाँ से नहीं  इख्तयार है !

 

 

                  

Monday, February 1, 2021

Bane of Democracy

 

Bane of Democracy

Last week we celebrated or observed the 72nd Republic Day on January 26 both with traditional gaiety on the Rajpath and unfortunate violent happenings at and around our symbol of freedom The Lal Kila (Red Fort) in the wake of the ongoing farmer’s protest against the agricultural laws. The day of self introspection has come if we want to save and preserve our Republic and Independence. Let us do that; the sooner the better.

Frankly, I don’t find anybody at hand to guide us in this regard except the visionary Babasaheb Ambedkar whom I repeatedly quote in such assertions. I don’t have any option. The Lal Kila incidents and the increasing unrest all around is a matter of worry and concern. The emerging situation before it becomes the ‘Bane of Democracy’ should be arrested and I quote Ambedkar in this regard who showed us the way to ward off the lingering danger to our democratic edifice. He said in his last speech in the Constituent Assembly on November 25, 1949 at the time of final enactment and adoption of the constitution, "If we wish to maintain democracy not merely in form, but also in fact, what must we do? 

The first thing in my judgement we must do is to hold fast to constitutional methods of achieving our social and economic objectives. It means we must abandon the bloody methods of revolution. It means that we must abandon the method of civil disobedience, non-cooperation and satyagraha. When there was no


way left for constitutional methods for achieving economic and social objectives, there was a great deal of justification for unconstitutional methods. But where constitutional methods are open, there can be no justification for these unconstitutional methods. These methods are nothing but the Grammar of Anarchy and the sooner they are abandoned, the better for us.

The second thing we must do is to observe the caution which John Stuart Mill has given to all who are interested in the maintenance of democracy, namely, not “to lay their liberties at the feet of even a great man, or to trust him with power which enable him to subvert their institutions”. There is nothing wrong in being grateful to great men who have rendered life-long services to the country. But there are limits to gratefulness. As has been well said by the Irish Patriot Daniel O’Connel, no man can be grateful at the cost of his honour, no woman can be grateful at the cost of her chastity and no nation can be grateful at the cost of its liberty. This caution is far more necessary in the case of India than in the case of any other country. For in India, Bhakti or what may be called the path of devotion or hero-worship, plays a part in its politics unequalled in magnitude by the part it plays in the politics of any other country in the world. Bhakti in religion may be a road to the salvation of the soul. But in politics, Bhakti or hero-worship is a sure road to degradation and to eventual dictatorship.

The third thing we must do is not to be content with mere political democracy. We must make our political democracy a social democracy as well. Political democracy cannot last unless there lies at the base of it social democracy."

If we fail to heed to these warnings, we will do so at our own peril

Now I come to the next point. With the new constitution, we opted for the parliamentary system of government. Obviously, in the parliamentary system of government ‘the people’ are supreme through their elected representatives sitting in the Parliament. The government is run in the name of Mahamahim Rastrapati i.e. the President of India, constitutional head of the State. The real


executive powers rest with the Cabinet headed by the Prime Minister popularly elected by the people of India. The third organ of the state, Judiciary is supposed to be free and fair and independent. The necessary ‘checks and balances’ have been created in accordance with the ‘Division of Powers’ clearly stipulated in the constitution. In more than 7 decades, the process of our constitutional and democratic setup has seen many ups and downs. By and large, we remained on track in spite of the fact that in all these years we could not evolve political culture based on ‘ideology and agenda’, unfortunately. Of late, it seems, we are losing the ground and direction in this regard which may prove to be costly and detrimental to our parliamentary democracy. Let me remind you of the assertions made by Ambedkar on our parliamentary democracy to set the thinking in right perspective. He said, “On the 26th of January 1950, India would be a democratic country in the sense that India from that day would have a government of the people, by the people and for the people. The same thought comes to my mind. What would happen to her democratic Constitution? Will she be able to maintain it or will she lose it again? This is the second thought that comes to my mind and makes me as anxious as the first.

It is not that India did not know what Democracy is. There was a time when India was studded with republics, and even where there were monarchies, they were either elected or limited. They were never absolute. It is not that India did not know Parliaments or parliamentary procedure.

This democratic system India lost. Will she lose it a second time? I do not know. But it is quite possible in a country like India – where democracy from its long disuse must be regarded as something quite new – there is danger of democracy giving place to dictatorship. It is quite possible for this new born democracy to retain its form but give place to dictatorship in fact. If there is a landslide, the danger of the second possibility becoming actuality is much greater.”

These assertions of Ambedkar are ‘food for thought’ to save our democracy. An immediate provocation to write about the dwindling spirit of parliamentary democracy came from the oppositions ‘collective boycott of the President’s customary Address to the joint session of the Parliament on January 29, 2021. We all know that President’s Address pertains to the agenda and policies of the government of the day then what is the need to undermine the tradition, convention and spirit of the constitution while professing norms of a parliamentary democracy. It is a willful and avoidable negation of the constitution which is harmful to our basic edifice. Yes, opposition may raise questions and say their part of the story in the pursuing debate on motion of thanks. Nobody can or should stop them. PM Narendra Modi rightly urged the opposition and all MPs to debate issues of national importance in Parliament and said “The first session of this decade is commencing today. This decade is very important for the bright future of India. A golden opportunity…to fulfill the dreams of freedom fighters. There should be discussions and presentation of different views for meaningful results.”

Let us listen from the horse’s mouth. Ambedkar spoke at DAV College Jalandhar on October 28, 1951 on the theme of parliamentary democracy and I quote him for the benefit of my readers. He said, inter alia,” Personally speaking, I am very attached to the Parliamentary system of Government. We must understand what it means and we must preserve it in constitution. What is meant by Parliamentary Government? There is a book on the English Constitution written by Walter Begot; it is indeed a classic treatise. It


was later expanded by other authorities on constitutional government like Laski and others. He has put the conception of the Parliamentary Government in one sentence. He says Parliamentary Government means government by discussion and not by fisticuffs. You will always find in the British system of Government that they hardly ever resort to fisticuffs when taking any decision. The decision is always taken after discussion. Nobody introduces the element of disturbance in the British parliament. Look at French Politics. Decisions are arrived at more than often by knocking knockout blows. He lamented that we in India are yet to learn this and said, “You will find that this system is hardly adequate to those not born in that system. It is an alien institution to them. We must learn, understand and make it a success.” In the same speech Babasaheb Ambedkar further said there were two important pillars of parliamentary democracy and asserted, “The Parliamentary system of Government is much more than government by discussion. There are two pillars on which the Parliamentary system of Government rests. These are the fulcrums on which the mechanism works. Those two pillars are an opposition and free and fair elections”

We are to think as to where we fit in? Of late, opposition is almost decimated. The ruling outfits are succumbing to ‘majoritarian ‘approach, it seems. The aspect of free and fair elections is completely over-powered by ‘money bags and muscle power’. The Election Commission, supposed to be free and fair and also independent, is increasingly seen as partisan by the political parties and practitioners of politics. We must address these issues; the sooner the better.

The more I read and understand Ambedkar; the more I am convinced of his intellect and vision in this regard. His interventions and speeches in the Constituent Assembly speak loudly and candidly on the parliamentary democracy and related subjects. Here I quote yet another aspect which clearly set the matter of discussion, opposition, differing approaches etc in their right perspective. Hope our MPs and MLAs read and benefit from these while sitting in the august Houses. Ambedkar said, “The task of the Drafting Committee would have been a very difficult one if this Constituent Assembly has been merely a motley crowd, a tessellated pavement without cement, a black stone here and a white stone there is which each member or each group was a law unto itself. There would have been nothing but chaos…

… The proceedings of this Constituent Assembly would have been very dull if all members had yielded to the rule of party discipline. Party discipline, in all its rigidity, would have converted this Assembly into a gathering of yes men.”

.We may see the grace in Ambedkar’s approach in dealings with the differing views of his colleagues in the Constituent Assembly. It requires to be emulated by our leaders in the Parliament and Legislative Assemblies -“That I was not prepared to accept their suggestions does not diminish the value of their suggestions nor lessen the service they have rendered to the Assembly in enlivening its proceedings. I am grateful to them. But for them, I would not have had the opportunity which I got for expounding the principles underlying the Constitution which was more important than the mere mechanical work of passing the Constitution.” He further said, “The Constitution can provide only the organs of State such as the Legislature, the Executive and the Judiciary. The factors on which the working of those organs of the State depends are the people and the political parties they will set up as their instruments to carry out their wishes and their politics.”

I think it is enough and I close here. It is time to think, consider and standup to save our democratic edifice, if wish to make and see India relevant in the years to come.

 

 

 

Tuesday, January 26, 2021

Kisan Andolan and Bharat Sarkar

 

Kisan Andolan and Bharat Sarkar

(A Sure Way to “Grammar of Anarchy”)

India i.e. Bharat has entered into its adulthood of democratic set-up enshrined in its constitution which came into effect on January 26, 1950. India got its independence from Britain on August 15, 1947 after a long struggle which we proudly term as the freedom movement. So far so good, India has remained India because of its constitution. It is a matter of satisfaction. Over the years, India has come a long way under the rule and governance by successive governments led by a number of political stalwarts as Prime Ministers. But it still has to go a longer way to reach though it can be


safely said that ‘India has arrived’. The journey in the process has been instructive and interesting under the constitutional framework so wisely and laboriously given to us by our forefathers led by visionary leaders like Babasaheb Ambedkar, Jawaharlal Nehru, Sardar Patel, Syama Prasad Mukherjee, Maulana Abul Kalam Azad, Babu Rajinder Prasad to name a few among others.

With this background, let me elaborate a bit as to why I said that ‘India remained India’ because of the constitution? In the 1950s and even early 1960s, some sort of skepticism was made to linger – Who after Nehru?  -  A subtle message that perhaps there will be chaos after Nehru. But the power was handed down and transferred in a democratic way after Nehru’s demise in May, 1964 from Lal Bahadur Shastri to Indira Gandhi. Indira Gandhi remained a powerful and effective PM for a long time. She took momentous decisions during her tenures as PM. Under the constitutional arrangements, the strongest PM Indira Gandhi was unseated from the Lok Sabha by the court in an election petition. In the aftermath, the constitution came under stress which resulted in Emergency in 1975 in the wake of a public awakening under the JP Movement. Our constitution stood the test of time in spite of attempts to undermine it; Indira Gandhi could not digest more and had to declare elections in February/March, 1977 which she and her party lost miserably to the new resurgent political outfits. It could happen only because of the constitution of India. The new outfits could not hold and face the emerged challenges. People brought Indira Gandhi to power again. Another test came; Indira Gandhi was eliminated from the scene violently in October, 1984. What happened?  Nothing; there was smooth change of guard. Yet another test happened; Rajiv Gandhi was assassinated in May, 1991. Again the system remained on track; democratic miracles happened, good leaders like Narsimha Rao, V.P. Singh, I.K. Gujral, Chadra Shekhar , Deve Gowda held the fort ably, with an abrasion of Charan Singh who had no agenda except his misplaced aspiration to become the PM,  and made way for the stalwarts like Atal Bihari Vajpayee and Manmohan Singh. The constitution could hold the system with or without full majority in the parliament for the ruling elite under consensus and political alliances. The only flip side which could be noticed was that our political democracy could not evolve political culture and polarization on the basis of ideology or agenda. Another type of undesirable communal polarization came to the fore which brought to power right wing Hindutva leaders under the umbrella of BJP with Narendra Modi in the lead and blessings of RSS in May/June, 2014. In this exercise, the matter of gratification remained as all this happened under the provisions of the constitution. The opposition and some marginalized and minority groups have been alleging subversion of the constitution and negation of its values. And on the other side, the right wing BJP and RSS have been sounding to revisit the constitution to accommodate the Hindutva aspirations of the majority Hindus. These assertions are debatable but at the same time dangerous. We should not be oblivious of the warnings of the chief architect of the constitution, Dr. B.R. Ambedkar given in his last speech in the Constituent Assembly when he surmised whether India would lose its independence again. If we don’t pay heed to these warnings, we would do so at our own peril.

With this longish backdrop, I come to the subject – Kisan Andolan and Bharat Sarkar – the ongoing farmers’ agitation and government of India not as an expert but as a concerned citizen of India. The thrust of my presentation would mainly be to bring the thoughts of Babasaheb Ambedkar to focus to deal with the challenges. I think besides many more assertions and statements, Dr. Ambedkar’s speech of November 25, 1949 in the Constituent Assembly is as relevant today as it was before. Farmers are agitating against the new agricultural laws made by PM Narendra Modi’s government,


allegedly without prior consultations with the entire stakeholders and hurriedly/undemocratically passed in parliament. The agitating farmers demand to repeal the laws and sit with them to address the issues afresh. The agitating farmers have been blocking the entry points to the capital city of Delhi for the last nearly two months in a peaceful protest. Government tried to dissuade them and subtly branded the agitation as ‘conspired and propped up by the opposition’ for political brownie points and sometimes tried to tarnish the peaceful protest by terming it as ‘overtaken and high jacked by anti-national forces of Khalistan, Urban Naxals, illegal funds from abroad, supported by Pakistan and China etc. on one hand and officially talking and negotiating with the farmer leaders on the other. Even after 11 rounds of talks so far there is a complete deadlock and standoff. No solution seems in sight. The situation is getting tense and worrisome in the run up to the Republic Day on January 26 in the wake of the farmers’ decision to have their Tractor March on the streets of Delhi to observe the Republic Day in protest against the farm laws. It may be said, to cut the story short, farmers profess to exercise their democratic right to oppose the laws which, they think,  are detrimental to their interests and demand repeal of these said to be ‘black laws’. Government of PM Narendra Modi has been maintaining throughout that the laws are good and beneficial to the farmers and the country at large on one side and showed willingness to amend these to satisfy the agitating farmers on the other. It seems a contradicting approach on the part of the government. Either the laws are good and should remain or these are bad which may be amended or repealed. It means the problem lies somewhere else. The agitating farmers are adamant on their demands and are braving the harsh cold weather on the outskirts of Delhi under trying conditions. Government, it seems, is standing on its ego under their notions of ‘majoritarian’ approach which itself is a negation of democratic principles.  Even the Supreme Court could not offer any acceptable solution and way out. The situation is getting dangerous by each passing day which is really a matter of concern to the society and the country. Unfortunately, most of the media particularly the electronic media which is called the fourth pillar of the democratic polity is totally biased in favour of the ruling dispensation and people tend to term it as ‘Godi Media’. Yet another disturbing factor which undermines the unity and integrity of the country is that the vested interests, knowingly or otherwise, are increasingly trying to make the standoff as conflict between the Sikhs and the Hindus and some others as war between the poor and the rich. It has resulted in avoidable acrimony and animosity adversely affecting the social fabric of the society. There is a real danger that the agitation may turn violent, if not handled deftly, resulting into real crisis detrimental to the security of the country. These are dangerous trends which would tend to put our democratic set and independence into ‘jeopardy’ as apprehended by Dr. Ambedkar in his speech referred to in the proceeding narration. Some sane voices are emerging to deal with the situation as the Hindustan Times in its editorial note on January 22 stated – “Farmers must shed rigidity – The Government retreated (with the proposal to withhold the laws for 12-18 months). Protesting groups should have reciprocated.” I personally could not understand how holding the laws in abeyance would help? Only time would tell as to which direction the situation heads. But we have to alert and cautious.

Now I come to the crux as to what should be done or could be done in the light of the democratic edifice of the country and spirit of the constitution as visualized by the great visionary of contemporary times, Babasaheb Ambeddkar. I will touch upon only on two points made by Ambedkar which are most relevant to ward of the lingering danger in the prevailing and emerging scenario. One, the increasing communal divide and priority and acceptance to conflicting ideologies over national interests tend to create problems. Referring to these and his worry about the independence of our country Ambedkar said, “Will history repeat itself? It is this thought that fills me with anxiety. This anxiety is deepened by the realization of the fact that in addition to our old enemies in the form of castes and creeds we are going to have many political parties with diverse and opposing political creeds. Will Indians place the country above their creed or will they place creed above country? I do not know. But this much is certain that if the parties place creed above country, our independence will be put in jeopardy a second time and probably be lost forever. This eventuality we must all resolutely guard against. We must be determined to defend our independence with the last drop of our blood.” Is there any need to elaborate this? I don’t think so. The sooner, our political leadership and intellectual class understand this, the better. The common citizen would tend to follow suit. It would bring in the much needed cohesiveness in our polity and society. The second is rather important with reference to the ongoing farmer’s agitation. In the same speech, the father of the constitution further said and gave these three warnings, “If we wish to maintain democracy not merely in form, but also in fact, what must we do?

The first thing in my judgment we must do is to hold fast to constitutional methods of achieving our social and economic objectives. It means we must abandon the bloody methods of revolution. It means that we must abandon the method of civil disobedience, non-cooperation and satyagraha. When there was no way left for constitutional methods for achieving economic and social objectives, there was a great deal of justification for unconstitutional methods. But where constitutional methods are open, there can be no justification for these unconstitutional methods. These methods are nothing but the Grammar of Anarchy and the sooner they are abandoned, the better for us.

The second thing we must do is to observe the caution which John Stuart Mill has given to all who are interested in the maintenance of democracy, namely, not “to lay their liberties at the feet of even a great man, or to trust him with power which enable him to subvert their institutions”. There is nothing wrong in being grateful to great men who have rendered life-long services to the country. But there are limits to gratefulness. As has been well said by the Irish Patriot Daniel O’Connell, no man can be grateful at the cost of his honour, no woman can be grateful at the cost of her chastity and no nation can be grateful at the cost of its liberty. This caution is far more necessary in the case of India than in the case of any other country. For in India, Bhakti or what may be called the path of devotion or hero-worship, plays a part in its politics unequalled in magnitude by the part it plays in the politics of any other country in the world. Bhakti in religion may be a road to the salvation of the soul. But in politics, Bhakti or hero-worship is a sure road to degradation and to eventual dictatorship.

The third thing we must do is not to be content with mere political democracy. We must make our political democracy a social democracy as well. Political democracy cannot last unless there lies at the base of it social democracy.”

Again, I think, there is no need to add anything to these thoughtful assertions made by Babasaheb Ambedkar. The message is clear and candid. India is passing through a difficult phase. We the people of India must understand this seriously. I conclude this with Hearty Greetings on the Republic Day and a poetic warning in the words of Allama Iqbal:

Chupa kar aastinoo mai bijliyan rakhi hai gardon ne

Anadil bagh k gafil na baithey aashiyanoo mai’

(The sky has kept thunderbolts concealed up its sleeve; garden’s nightingales should not slumber in their nests.)

 

(Blog of Ambassador Ramesh Chander)

 

 

 

Saturday, January 16, 2021

From Mochi’s Theeha to IGNOU – Book Review

 

From Mochi’s Theeha to IGNOU – Book Review

(MOCHI – Ek Mochi Ka Adbi Zindginama)

While reading Dwarka Bharti’s recently released book - MOCHI – Ek Mochi Ka Adbi Zindginama), I was reminded of a famous phrase – From Log House to the White House -  attributed to President Abraham Lincoln of the USA and thought of giving the title - From
Mochi’s Theeha (shed) to IGNOU
(Indira Gandhi National Open University) for the book review in hand. The book Mochi was released some days ago at the Budh Vihar at Sidharath Nagar (Bootan Mandi), Jalandhar, my native place, at a simple ceremony by invoking the Trisharan – Buddhist invocation by Harmesh Jassal, and launched by a renowned writer and rational thinker, Dr. Surinder Ajnat in the presence of  ardent Buddhists and staunch Ambedkarites, Lahori Ram Balley and Ramesh Sidhu both intellectual friends of the author, Dwarka Bharti. It has been published by Navchetna Publications of Varinder Kumar. I could guess that Dwarka Bharti was also a Buddhist, an enlightened person in the literary sense of the word. Dwarka Bharti himself wrote in Chapter 8 of the book – The Baghi Mochi - that the vagaries of life and literature had changed the course of my life. I was not simply a cobbler now who nailed in the sole of shoes but a rebel (Baghi) who will nail and stand against the people who had been nailing the society for long. The entire narrative in the book dwells on this theme of transformation from a low caste Hindu and a follower of Radha Soami of Beas to the equitable order of Gautama Buddha. In the process, it is evident that Dwarka Bharti has really come a long way from a marginalized Mochi to a recognized Intellectual with his sheer mental and spiritual faculties in spite of the fact that he did not get opportunity to get formal educational degrees. He participates in prestigious literary meets and seminars, writes in acclaimed literary magazines and papers, worked on the coveted position of a member of the syllabus committee of IGNOU as a proud literary personality. Dwarka Bharti is also one of past Presidents of Ambedkar Mission Society of Jalandhar like Surinder Ajnat. The book makes a good reading.  The life of the author could hold as a good motivational story. The book has been rightly dedicated to “Andheron Ko Bedhne Mein Sanlagn Tamaam Kalmon Ke Naam” (to the pens engaged in removal of darkness).

The introduction of the book has been written by the author’s long time friend and guide and himself a literary personality of standing Dr. Surinder Ajnat who also launched the book. Justifying the title of this review – From Mochi KA Theeha (shed) to IGNOU – let me endorse Dr. Ajnat’s comment on Dwarka Bharti’s poem which forms the part of post graduate course in IGNOU – Aaj Ka Eklavya – “Bharti ji Ki Bhasha Bahut Sashakt, Chust aur Vishyanukul Hai. Us Mein Vyangaarth Ka Udaharan Dun To Yeh Hoga: Ki Ab Angutha ‘Katvaiya’ Nahin Jayega, Sirf ‘Dikhaya’ Jayega” (now the thumb will not be allowed to be cut instead it will be used as a symbol of revolt).

In the prologue – EK Nazar Idhar, the author himself says that the book was not an expression of self-pity – “Prastut Zindginama Ek Mochi Ki Rudankatha Nahin Hai Balki Chamde Ko Mathne Ke Saath Saath Ek Aise Sahityik Mochi Ke Jiwan Ki Katha Ke Mukhya Ansh Hain.” The book has been divided into 9 chapters starting with Mochi Ka Theeha (Shed of a cobbler) and concludes with his poem “Aaj Ka Eklavya” which is prescribed in the syllabus of MA classes of IGNOU – From Mochi Ka Theeha to IGNOU. Dwarka Bharti has no inferiority complex that he is a Mochi and rightly so. He narrates interesting stories of his school days where even the teachers like Vidya Sagar among others treated him shabbily because of his low place in the social hierarchy. The caste divide and discriminatory treatment even at Radha Soami Dera aptly explain the deplorable practices at our centers of spiritual and social outfits. The author tells a curious incident when his own father-in-law Mani Ram scolds him, with disdain, that he (Dwarka Bharti) was nothing but a Mochi and should remain in his lowly limits. This incident touched the author’s sensitivities and pushed him further to rebel against the social order based on inequalities. The author’s sojourns to Jordan and Iraq for earning his bread and butter helped in opening his vision further which helped him in carrying forward his interest in literature.  As regards his contact and interaction in the literary circles particularly the so called “Dalit Sahitya”, while reading the narration one virtually finds a directory of Who’s Who in the academic and intellectual sphere. This easily explains that Dwarka Bharti enjoys a status of wide recognition in literary circles of India. Yet another interesting feature of the book, at least for me, remained that some well known names whom I happen to know personally do appear in the book as associates and co-players of the author namely; Lahori Ram Balley, Surinder Ajnat, Gian Singh Bal, Mohan Lal Philloria, Balbir Madhopuri, Desh Raj Kali among others. It was a matter of gratification for me to learn further about the life and mission of Gian Singh Bal from the book. The Chapter – Ek Baghi Mochi says all about the transformed status and state of mind of the author who termed himself as “Nir-ishwarwadi” who stands against social ills generated and perpetuated by “Ishwarwad” of various religious orders. There are many more like Dwarka Bharti and I have nothing to comment on his candid view point. But sometimes, as a layman, I surmise as to why liberated or transformed minds should be dogmatic about certain things? Dwarka Bharti is a practicing cobbler or Mochi but he consciously chooses not to hang a picture of Guru Ravidass, the lone icon of all Mochis, at his Theeha (shed). I could see the picture of Babasaheb Ambedkar at the author’s work place. Frankly, I find a tinge of some sort of complex, perhaps subconsciously, in the mind of the author. I don’t think even Lord Buddha professed this kind of rigidity or dogmatism. The answer may lie in the fact that we are still to go a long way in the journey to liberate ourselves from narrow considerations. Nevertheless, I fully know we are all human.

I take this opportunity to congratulate and thank Dwarka Bharti and Navchetna publishers for giving us much needed food for thought in their book - Mochi to face and address the societal maladies. I recommend the book to my friends and discerning public. With this, I conclude with a Shabad of Guru Ravidass which says much:

ਨੀਚੋਂ ਉਂਚ ਕਰੇ ਮੇਰਾ ਗੋਬਿੰਦ;

ਕਹੁ ਤੇ ਨਾ ਡਰੇ !

 

 

 

 

 

 

Thursday, January 14, 2021

Babu Mangu Ram Mugowalia – A Tribute

 

Babu Mangu Ram Mugowalia – A Tribute

The birth anniversary of Babu Mangu Ram Mugowalia (January 14, 1886 – April22, 1980) falls on January 14. I have been writing off and own in the Ambedkar Times and my Blog: diplomatictitbits.blogspot.in on the life and mission of Babu Mangu


Ram “Prophet of dalit struggle in Punjab” as termed by Prof Ronki Ram of the Punjab University, Chandigarh. I thought of remembering the great dalit icon Babu Mangu Ram Mugowalia again as a humble tribute to him for his pioneering contribution for the emancipation of the marginalized sections of the society in the early years of the 20th century under the banner of Ad-dharam Movement which was founded by him in 1925-26 on his return from the democratic world abroad and his sterling role in the Gadar Movement in the USA for the independence of India.

Initially, the ad-dharam movement was initiated by Vasant Rai,  Achutanand among others as a ‘reform movement’ of Hindus under of Arya Samaj to counter Christians, Muslims and Sikhs who were targeting dalits to join them under the arrangements of communal divide initiated by the British rulers in 1909 and further strengthened in 1919 which ultimately resulted in the ‘Communl Award” of PM Ramsey MacDonald in 1932 after the Round Table Conferences. It goes without saying that the Communal Award was the outcome of untiring efforts set in motion of the Memorandum of Ad-dharam Mandal submitted to the Governor of Punjab in 1929 which was rightly called “Magna Carta of dalits” and aptly pleaded and registered by Babasaheb Ambedkar in the Round Table Conferences against a stiff opposition by Mahatma Gandhi and the Hindu leadership at large who wanted to keep dalits under the subjugation of upper caste Hindus. The Ad-dharam Mandal under the stewardship of Babu Mangu Ram Mugowalia stood by Dr. B.R. Ambedkar when he was struggling for registering his view point for the emancipation of the depressed classes from the tyranny of caste Hindus. The rest is history.

With Babu Mangu Ram Mugowalia’s expose to the liberal ideas of the USA and his work and interaction with the Gadari Babas made him revolt against the social discrimination of the caste Hindus against the depressed people under the caste system. He foundered Ad-dharam Mandal, in cooperation and coordination with his likeminded colleagues and declared the following as their motive and agenda, as written by Prof. Ronki Ram in one of his articles on the subject, “The leaders of Ad Dharm thus chose to restore dignity and freedom to the untouchables by detaching them completely from Hinduism and consolidating them into their own ancient religion – Ad Dharm— of which they had become oblivious during the long domination by the ‘alien Hindus’. In fact, the task of reviving their ancient religion was not an easy one, for the untouchables had forgotten their Gurus and other religious symbols during long period of persecution at the hands of the Savarnas. They had been condemned as impure and declared unfit to have their own theology. Thus, to revive Ad Dharm was tantamount to developing a new religion for the Achhuts. Mangu Ram’s claim that the Dalits were the real inhabitants of this land made an enormous psychological impact on the untouchables, providing a theological podium to sustain and reinforce the new Dalit identity.”Manyawar  Kanshi Ram, a dalit icon who brought the marginalized sections of the society to the political map of the country in recent times to carry forward the mission of Babu Mangu Ram, explained the agenda and rationale of Ad-dharam Movement in one of his public speeches in Hoshiarpur and said, “What is Ad-dharm? To tell people about this, I have called this meeting at this place. The Ad-dharm movement was the movement of rebellion against the Hindu religion. It was the movement against the Manuwad. A religion that mistreated and exploited Chamars for years and years, Ad-dharm movement was the movement against that oppression. It was the rebellion against all those atrocities. Ad-Dharm movement was the revolt against the Hinduism.”

The agenda and mission of Ad-dharam Movement and Babu Mangu Ram was clear and candid in establishing the dalit identity separate from the Hindus and Sikhs as Moolniwasis of the land. The contribution of Babu Mangu Ram and Ad-dhram Movement in this regard was immense and appreciable. It must be recorded in history in its right perspective. The subsequent developments like the Poona Pact of 1932 signed between Mahatma Gandhi and Dr. B.R. Ambedkar in the wake of the Communal Award, independence of India in 1947 and the new constitution of India and also Babasaheb Ambedkar’s embracing of Buddhism in 1956 changed the political and social scenario which resulted in diminished relevance of Ad-dharam Movement. But the impact and contribution of the Movement, nevertheless, will remain in the dalit consciousness for long years to come.

It is a matter of satisfaction that the mission of Babu Mangu Ram Mugowalia with appropriate changes to cater to the needs of changing scenario is being followed and promoted by All India Ad-dharam Mission under the leadership of Sant Satwinder Singh Hira of Khuralgarh Sahib, historic site pertaining to Guru Ravidass ji, in Hoshiarpur district of Punjab and many other outfits. I take this opportunity to wish them all the best in realizing the lofty ideal of establishing a casteless and equitable society as visualized by Babu Mangu Ram Mugowalia.

With this I close here with Naman to Babu Mangu Ram Mugowalia on his birth anniversary as my humble tribute to the great leader.

ਹਜ਼ਾਰੋਂ ਸਾਲ ਨਰਗਿਸ ਆਪਣੀ ਬੇਨੂਰੀ ਪੈ ਰੋਤੀ  ਹੈ ,

ਬੜੀ ਮੁਸ਼ਕਿਲ ਸੇ ਹੋਤਾ ਹੈ ਚਮਨ ਮੈਂ ਦੀਦਾਵਰ  ਪੈਦਾ !