The Indian Census – The Dalit Perspective
The upcoming Census, 2027 presents an important aspect of the emerging socio-political scenario with regard to the Scheduled Castes commonly called Dalits. Here are the key parameters which
intersect with Dalit populations. The term Dalit is used for those who were so called "untouchables" and others that were outside of the traditional Hindu caste hierarchy.
Official Classification: Dalits are officially recognized in government
records as Scheduled Castes (SCs), a category that currently enumerates Hindu,
Sikh, and Buddhist Dalits. The 2011 Census officially logged over 201 million
SCs.
The 2027 Census: The upcoming decennial count will expand its demographic
scope, with plans to collect broader socio-economic and caste details. This
broader enumeration has sparked debate within Dalit communities regarding how
to balance specific caste identities with religious identity to protect state
benefits (Reservations).
Conversion and Status: Disclosing conversion to Christianity or Islam can affect
legal access to state benefits and reservations tied to the traditional
Dalit/SC identity.
I will confine my study only to Dalits as, of late; it has been
observed that this time Dalits of various denominations are slowly getting more
vocal about their identity separate from that of Hindus and Sikhs. Though the
enumeration in the census is being done on the basis of constitutional
provisions with regard to religion and caste and as such only; Hindus, Sikhs,
Buddhists, Jains, Muslims, Christians and other smaller denominations yet
Dalits are presenting
their case as a separate entity and identity in view of
the historical background of Hindu hierarchy and struggle of oppressed and
depressed people – so called untouchables, SCs, Dalits etc. My recent informal
interaction with some of the concerned and knowledgeable intellectuals of the
Dalit community; Manohar
Mahey, Sat Paul Virdi, Balbir Chander, Gian Kaul, Harmesh Jassal, Baldev Bhardwaj, Sohan Sehjal, Harbans Virdee, Charan Dass Sandhu, Varindra Kumar, Paramjit Mahey among others presenting Ad-dharm (Moolnivasi), Ravidassia Religion, Buddhism, has thrown some the facts about the Census and the Dalit communities. I will try to put across these with my own observations not as an academic or expert but as a concerned citizen and member of the Dalit community.
Going by the current scenario, there are, to my mind, the
following four prepositions for the so called Dalits which require
consideration and action. One may find my views untraditional and may not find
easy understanding but someone has to state the reality -
1. Remain Hindus as Born
– Majority of Dalits, due to ignorance and backwardness, do not pay much attention and consideration to the issue and are totally oblivious of their Hindu identity. They remain what they are as they were born to Hindu parents. They, knowingly or otherwise, remain with the main stream of the society that is Hinduism. It is a fact that Hinduism did not treat, the so called ‘Untouchables or Outcastes’ outside the Varna System of Manu, well for centuries together. Right from the Saints of the Bhakti Movement of 15-16th century to down the lines to Babasaheb Ambedkar till mid 1930s tried their best to reform Hindu religion and integrate the so called Dalits to the main stream of the Hindu society as equal partners. But they failed miserably as the very edifice of Hindu society is based on graded inequality as ordained in Manusmriti and other Hindu scriptures. Political developments, in the run up to India’s independence, in the contemporary times starting from the establishment of Ad-dhram Mandal in 1926 and acceptance of its demand to include Ad-dhram as a religion in the Census of 1931 as a distinct (non-Hindu) identity of Dalits, the Round Table Conferences in London in the early years of 1930s, Communal Award of PM Ramsey MacDonald in 1932 providing separate electorates to Dalits, Poona Pact of 1932 signed between the caste Hindus led by Mahatma Gandhi and Babasaheb Ambedkar, India Act of 1935 and finally the Constitution of independent India which came into effect in January 1950, changed the socio-political and also socio-religious scenario with adopting the cardinal principles of Secularism, Socialism and Democracy in the constitution. Dalits are empowered and they are trying their best to stand up and claim their rightful place in the socio-political space both in the polity a society. Though the caste discrimination still persists yet Dalits have tended to show their resolve to oppose the discrimination tooth and nail. It is almost certain that things would come to head if the so called upper castes and main stream of thesociety don’t come around and respect Dalits and bring about Samrasta as visualized by RSS and other right wing Hindu outfits. The ground realities are fast coming to surface that Dalits are no more interested in remaining at the margins of the society. They are ready to fight from within and stand for their equal space and ground in the society as Hindus. The caste Hindus need to go an extra mile in this regard coming out of the lip service., if they are interested in keeping the Hindu citadel safe and secure. This was the scenario one.
Mein Nahin Sandesh SwaragKa Laya
Is Bhutal Ko Hi Swarag Banane Aya
2. Independent Identity as Ad-dharmi (Moolnivasi) – The second proposition for Dalits is to assert themselves and claim separate identity (Non-Hindus) as the original inhabitants of India, separate from Aryans who came from outside India and subjugated the original inhabitants; Dalits (outside the Varna system of Hindus)–
Ad-dharmis or Moolvivasis. It is not a new or concept and has historical context. Dravids in the South represented by Periyar Ramsamy Naicker and Dalits represented by Ad-dhram Mandal of Babu Mangu Ram Mugowalia established in June, 1926 (Some months ahead of RSS). The Ad-dharm Mandal has as all the ingredients and parameters (Jhnda, Book, Slogan, Salutation, Agenda, Roadmap) to qualify as an outfit to claim separate identity for Dalits separate from Hindus and even other denominations like Sikhs (recent offshoots from Hinduism). The British rulers, in their own wisdom, and historical oppression and suppression of Dalits by the caste hierarchies of Hindus, recognized the claims of Ad-dharm Mandal in 1931 Census and enumerated them as Ad—dhramis. The caste-Hindus opposed it tooth and nail but failed. The subsequent developments as explained in the first proposition above changed the entire scenario. The Hindu leadership led by Mahatma Gandhi, Madan Mohan Malviya to begin with and later the Hindu leadership of RSS/Jan Sangh/BJP and their affiliates, by hook and crook, succeeded in making Dalits as an appendix of the main stream of the society to save Hinduism. They succeeded in cheating and
blackmailing even Babasaheb Ambedkar in the Poona Pact and later prevailed upon him in the framing of the Constitution to appropriate Dalits as an integral part of Hindus. Babasaheb Ambedkar, a nationalist to the core and a visionary leader did his best in the given circumstances to save the country from divisive tendencies in the larger interests of the society at large. Dalits are to decide themselves these important aspects as bonafide Indian citizens who intend to live with human dignity, not as an appendix of the oppressive society, under the shelter of the Constitution of India. According 2011 Census, there were 201.4 million Dalits in India. In addition to it, Dalits live in peripheral countries like Bangladesh, Nepal, Sri Lanka, and Pakistan and also in countries in Europe, Canada, USA, and New Zealand among others. I recall an Urdu couplet –
Jo Dil Mein Hai; Woh Kehne Ki Himmat
Kyon Nahin Karte
Nahin Manjoor Hai Manjar; To Bagabat Kyon
Nahin Karte
3. Buddhism
– The third prop open to Dalits is to convert and embrace Buddhism. It was the stream chosen by Babasaheb Ambedkar after he got frustrated and could not reform Hinduism in the 1930s. In 1936, he pronounced that he was born a Hindu and it was not in his hands but will not as a Hindu which was in his hands. He took more than 20 years to fulfill his solemn pledge and formally embraced Buddhism at Nagpur (Diksha Bhoomi) on October 14, 1956 along with several lakhs of his followers. It was an epoch making development in the socio-religious realm not only in India but beyond too. It was the revival of Buddhism in India. His treatise on Buddhism – Buddha and His Dhamma is an authoritative account of Buddhism explained for the masses. Babasaheb was a man of vision and knowledge. He explained fully as to why he had taken this step to shed the scourge of graded inequality perpetuated in the society in the name of tenants of Manusamriti and other Hindu texts. From the day one of his embracing of Buddhism, Babasaheb started the work of making India ‘Buddhmai’ and motivated his followers to follow suit. He thoughtfully prepared the roadmap in this regard including taking help and support of Buddhist outfits in India and abroad. But it was not to be; he passed away (Parinirvana) on December 6, 1956 in less than two months of his starting the historic journey as aBoddhisatava. The conditions and climate changed; the lofty idea got a big jolt. The followers of Babasaheb mostly in Maharashtra followed by UP and Punjab picked the threads and tried to spread the idea but could not make any headway. As of now there are only less than 90 lakh Buddhists in India, a negligible figure in a country of 150 crorers. Meanwhile, the main stream of the society playing their usual card appropriated the Neo-Buddhists to their fold, as they did with the SC Sikhs earlier, by extending the provisions of Reservation to the Buddhists in 1990. The Hindu scheming lot even declared Gautama the Buddha as the Incarnation (Avtar) of Hindu deity Vishnu. Buddhists seem to be happy as an appendix of Hindus as SCs as they were. This preposition for Dalits to be Buddhists has no merit, to my mind. I am afraid many of my friends in the Ambedkarite circles will not like my candid views but we need to be pragmatic and truthful and even ‘Tarksheel’ in the light of what Buddha said ‘Apna Deepak Aap Bano – Be your own light’.
Jo Ashiana Sakhay Nazuk Pe Banega;
Na-paydar Hoga
R Ravidassia Dhram – This is fourth and last prop – Ravidassia Religion floated by Dera Sachkhand Ballan of Jalandhar in the wake of tragic and unfortunate incidents in Vienna (Austria) in May, 2009 in which Sant Ramanand was martyred by some Sikh fundamentalists and the present Head (Gaddi Nasheen) of the Dera, Sant Niranjan Dass was seriously wounded but survived. Ravidassia Dhram was formally launched in February, 2010 with ‘Har’ as its Singnia and Amritbani (Verses of Guru Ravidass) as its holy Granth. The Ravidassia Dharm is an independent religion established by
Dera Sach Khand Ballan, a prominent spiritual dera located in the village of Ballan, near Jalandhar, Punjab. It was formally declared to give the Ravidassia community a distinct religious identity. It was a jerk reaction of the Ad-dhrami community to give way to the pent up emotions against the Sikhs and notionally against the Hindus. Before this, Dera was adhering to the Sikh tenants as per the teachings of Guru Granth Sahib. I can easily say, as said it in 2010 too even at the risk of annoying many of my friends and fellow Ad-dhrmis; Ravidassia Dharm was a thoughtless and uncalled for step taken in hurry. It has, to my mind, further divided the community and has confined Dalits only to so called Chamars/Ad-dharmis of Hindu extraction. It has alienated Sikhs – Mazabi and Ravidassia extraction. The new Dhram has negated the idea and principles of Ad-dhram Mandal, an inclusive prop of Identity to the entire Dalit communities, of Babu Mangu Ram Mugowalia of which Sant Sarwan Dass of Sachkhand Ballan was a founding father. Dera Sachkhand Ballan had been the votary and proponent of Ad-dharm Movement right up to mid1970s when at a meeting at Ballan under the stewardship of Sant Sarwan Dass, Seth Khushi Ram, one of my fellow BootanMandians was appointed as the President of the outfit to carry forward the agenda of Dalit Identity to assert for our due space in the society. I am sorry to say that Ravidassia Dharm has distracted the community from getting united and struggle for its rights and space in the society at large. My friends in the community who support Ravidassia Dharm, as far as I know, has not done anything worthwhile under the current legal and procedural arrangements, to register and promote the newly floated outfit except talking in the air once in a while mainly as giving way to their emotionally charged minds. It has not taken them anywhere. My simple question as a layman is: Did Dera Sachkhand Ballan raise the issue of registration and recognition in the Census with PM Narendra Modi when he visited the Dera in February, 2026 and before that when Sant Niranjan Dass, the Gaddi Nasheen, met the PM at his residence last year? If yes, what was his response? If not, why not? I think, Ravidassia Dharm is not the answer to the requirements of dignified life and space in the society. Dalits would remain an appendix of Hindus as we are. Ravidassia Dharm has no locus standi in the matter. Let us be pragmatic and find our way forward in the current socio-political situation in the country.
Andhi Ke Jhonkon Se; Jhuk Jayen Jis
Tehjibo Tammadun Ki Sakhaine
Hum Aisi Nazuk Sakhaon Per; Tamire
Nasheman Kya Karte
The Prognosis - All said and done, let us proceed towards the prognosis as
to what should be done to strengthen the social fabric of the Indian society on
one hand and get due space and share and dignified identity to Dalits, the
marginalized sections of the society as stipulated and visualized by our
forefathers led by Babasaheb Ambedkar in the Constitution of India and the
relevant statues of India that is Bharat. Most of the Dalits are landless and
economically weak Hindus. If we really intend to make India that is Bharat
belong “We the people of India’ as enshrined in the Constitution of India, we
need to make the India an inclusive and all-embracing society; secular,
socialist, democratic. With this background, Dalits, to my mind, have only two
options; ad-seriatim –
1.
Remain as Hindus - Dalits are Hindus and should remain so unless and until anyone of them
does not voluntarily opt to convert to some other stream like; Islam. Christianity,
Sikhism, Jainism, Buddhism or any other. Though as of now Dalits are still
fighting for their due space and dignified life in the Hindu fold due to
historic inhuman and condemnable Manuwadi system yet now a days Dalits are
getting fully empowered to challenge and undo the nefarious designs to keep
Dalits marginalized. Thanks to the winds of change due to the matching
provisions in the Constitution and the very edifice of the Indian polity and
society based on the cardinal principles of ‘Justice, Liberty, Equality and
Fraternity. In the 19th century, the Brahmo Samaj, Arya Samaj and
the Ramakrishna Mission actively participated in the
campaign of the rights of Dalits besides many more reform movements. Babasaheb
Ambedkar furthered and cemented the campaign by codifying the reform agenda in
the Constitution itself. Dalits are fully capable of defending themselves with
or without the so called Upper Castes.
Dalits will be Hindus at their own terms; it should be clear to the main
stream of the Hindu society, if India is to transform to Bharat. If the caste
Hindus will not understand this ground reality, they will do so at their own
peril. Dalits are no more interested in remaining as second rate citizens and
degraded human beings under any dispensation. Manuwad has to be eradicated,
annihilated and buried and Dalits shall live as equal partners and stakeholders
both in the polity and society.
Masjid
To Baa Di Pal bhar Mein; Iman Ki Hararat Walon Ne
Man
Apna Purana Papi Hai; Barson Se Namazi Ban Na Saka
Iqbal
Bada Updeshak Hai; Man Baton Se Moh Leta Hai
Guftar
Ka To Yeh Gazi Bana; Kirdar Ka Gazi Ban Na Saka
2. Distinct and separate Identity as Ad-dharmis (Moolnivasi) – Many well to do Dalits somehow feel, may be rightly so, that they cannot get due respect and dignity in Hindusism and even in Sikhism and must get their distinct identity as Ad-dharmis (Moolnivasis). The Ad-dhram Movement started by Babu Mangu Ram Mugowalia in Punjab in 1926 in the North of India and the Dravid Movement of Periyar Ramsamy Naicar in Tamil Nadu in the South floated the idea and carried forward through
the available legal procedures and by motivating the Dalit masses. In the 1931 Census, the British authorities recognized Ad-dharm as a separate entity separate from the Hindus. But the subsequent developments in the run up to reform in the Hindu society and independence of like: the Communal Award of 1932 providing separate electorates to Dalits, Poona Pact signed between Mahatma Gandhi and Babasaheb Ambedkar providing for Reservations to Dalits instead of Separate Electorates, Elections in 1937 in which Ad-dharm Mandal and its allies won about 10 seats in the Punjab Assembly, Abolishment of untouchability in the laws of the land, Empowerment and Affirmative provisions in the Constitution of India, Ambedkar’s embracing of Buudhism in 1956 tended to negate the agenda of the Ad-dharm Movement. In the process slowly the Movement became dormant in spite of the renewed endeavors of Babu Mangu Ram Mugowalia to revive the A-dharm Movement, it could not be sustained. Hindus, mindfully and tactfully, succeeded in appropriating Ad-dharm as a caste under the Hindu fold. If Dalits still feel strongly enough that there is no future for them in Hinduism as Hindus are not seriously and sincerely engaged to establish a casteless society and integrate Dalits with the main stream of the society as equal partners and stakeholders, they may consider and demand their separate Identity as Ad-dharmis (Moolnivasis). They are free to do so under the constitutional and civic norms as their demographic share is considerable enough to hold their demand – more than 25 crorers with almost 20% of the total Hindu population in the country. What let us see how could it be done? Is it that simple? The answer is big No. There is no Babu Mango Ram Mugowalia, Babasaheb Ambedkar, Periyar Ramasamy Naicker, Babu Kanshi Ram around. The Dalit leadership is divided among the Ad-dharmi, Ravidassias, Mazahbis, Kabirpanthis, Buddhists, Balmikis etc. under their several political hues and colors. The political reservations have made the political leadership ‘Stooges – Chamchas’ as termed by Babu Kanshi Ram. Dalit spiritual Deras are confused and are self-centered outfits. The Gaddi Nasheens and their coteries are contented by adding to their real estates and enjoying gun-wielding security rings around them provided by the governments. All these Deras, unfortunately, have become dens of self-seekers without any vision. They are not interested in engaging with the intelligentsia and academia of the community to chalk out the framework and roadmap for the identity of the Dalit masses. This is a painful narration but it is the truth speaking of ground realities. I have no intension to hurt the feelings of anyone as I am a simple and ordinary among them. If Dalits are to stand up and ask for their due, the only remedy is to take shelter under Babasaheb Ambedkar’s dictum – Educate, Agitate and Organize: Educate ourselves of the Dasha and Disha of the community, Agitate in our minds to study and identify the root causes of our backwardness and Organise to struggle and fight for our rights. It might require us to take our struggle to the corridors of power in New Delhi, chambers of decision making in the Parliament, chambers of justice in the courts and even to the streets for peaceful and
democratic expression of freedoms. In a democratic set up, the principle of ‘One vote one value’ has a lot of weight. Following the jargon of Babu Kanshi Ram – Vote Hamara Raj Tumhara; Nahin Chalega Nahin Chalega’; prepare yourself to grab political power through the constitutional means and process laid down by no one else but your own icon, Babasaheb Ambedkar. If we are prepared to do this, we have every right to ask for our own space and identity in the society. Otherwise the whole system – Tantar is heavily molded and titled towards the vested interests to keep Dalits under subjugation as long as possible. The divided and fragmented Dalits suit the oppressors to perpetuate their hold both on the polity and society. Dalits need to stand up and do themselves; nobody will help them, as a practicing diplomat, I may say it in diplomatic parlance, “No lunch is free in diplomacy.”
Tu
Pehle Baat; Phir Baat Ka Andaz Paida Kar
Phir
Tujhe duniyan Mein; Koi Nazar Andaz Kar Nahin Sakta
In conclusion, I may write again that it is a cursory
overview by a layman before Dalits approach the forthcoming census as it would
affect them greatly in the decades to come. I recall an Urdu couplet of Allama
Iqbal: -
Na pūchho mujh se lazzat ḳhānamāñ-barbād rahne kī
Nasheman saikḌoñ maiñ ne banā kar phūñk Daale haiñ












